Three generations of perfected recipes. Custom cakes, handmade pastries, and artisan desserts—crafted daily with intention. From intimate morning rituals to once-in-a-lifetime weddings.
Everything baked in-house daily. If it's on this list, it was made this morning from a recipe that's been in the family for decades.
13 specialty and 7 traditional flavors—including the White Rhapsody. Available as round, sheet, square, or heart-shaped. Custom decorations for any occasion, any size.
View PricingFrom first birthdays to Sweet 16s, our custom birthday cakes are made to order in all flavors and sizes. Join our Birthday Club and receive $3 off, every year.
Order YoursButtery danish with seasonal fruit fillings. Gooey sticky buns. Whoopie pies in chocolate, red velvet, and pumpkin. All ready before your morning coffee.
Come VisitHandmade cream puffs, cannoli, chocolate cups, fresh fruit tarts, petit fours, and dipped strawberries. Designed to impress at weddings, showers, and celebrations.
Request PricingShoo-fly, pecan, egg custard, coconut cream, pumpkin, lemon sponge—plus soft-baked cookies from sugar to chocolate chip. The kind of pies Lancaster is known for.
Find UsFresh orange, lemon poppy-seed, blueberry, pumpkin, and cranberry-orange quick breads. A fresh donut assortment baked and ready every morning without exception.
Call to CheckDesigned with you. Made to exceed every expectation.
Every cake is one-of-a-kind, matched to your vision.
From classic white to our signature White Rhapsody.
Sit with Diahann—no commitment, just possibilities.
Reviewed and recommended by Lancaster couples.
Your wedding cake is not just dessert—it's a centerpiece, a memory, a reflection of your love. Our specialist Diahann will guide you from the first sketch to the final layer, ensuring every detail is exactly right.
The proof is in the people who come back—year after year, celebration after celebration.
Our wedding cake was absolutely stunning and tasted even better than it looked. Diahann was patient, creative, and clearly passionate. Every guest commented on it.
The White Rhapsody cake is worth every penny. My family requests it for every birthday now. Three generations of recipes shows in every single bite. Best bakery in Lancaster.
I drove 45 minutes specifically for their sticky buns and whoopie pies. Worth every mile. The staff is wonderful and the products are genuinely exceptional. Don't miss this place.
Byers Butterflake Bakery has been a cornerstone of Lancaster County for generations. What began as a deep passion for quality baking has grown into a beloved local institution—trusted by families for their most meaningful moments.
Nothing mass-produced. Every item made in-house from original family recipes.
Find us at Roots Market in Manheim and New Eastern Market in York, not just Leola.
From birthday cakes to wedding centerpieces—every order is personal.
Perfected across three generations, tested and treasured by thousands of families.
"Our recipes have been perfected over three generations. We think—and we've been told—our products are second to none."
— The Byers Family
All cakes are available in traditional or specialty flavors. Standard buttercream decorations included. Custom artwork and licensed characters priced separately—call us to discuss your vision.
| Cake Type & Size | Serves | Traditional | Specialty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sheet Cakes | |||
| ¼ Sheet | ~15 | $36 | $43 |
| ½ Sheet | 30–35 | $62 | $72 |
| Full Sheet | 60–70 | $100 | $130 |
| Round Cakes | |||
| 8″ Round | ~15 | $36 | $43 |
| 9″ Round | 20–25 | $48 | $58 |
| 10″ Round | 25–35 | $62 | $72 |
| 12″ Round | 35–45 | $96 | $115 |
| Square & Heart Cakes | |||
| 8″ Square | 20–25 | $48 | $58 |
| 9″ Square | ~30 | $63 | $75 |
| 8″ Heart | 10–12 | $36 | $45 |
| 9″ Heart | 18–20 | $48 | $58 |
| 10″ Heart | ~25 | $62 | $75 |
Standard decorations include buttercream flowers, balloons, and confetti. Need something more? Call (717) 656-6803 to discuss custom options.
Register with your name, birthday, and email. We'll send you a coupon redeemable any time during your birth month. Limit one per family per birthday.
Our main bakery in Leola, plus weekly market presence in Manheim and York.
44 West Main Street
Leola, Pennsylvania
Mon–Fri: 7 AM – 5 PM
Saturday: 7 AM – 2 PM
✅ Online orders available for pickup. Curbside by request.
Get Directions →705 Graystone Road
Manheim, Pennsylvania
Tuesdays only
Market hours apply
Our Roots Country Market stand—full selection of baked goods available weekly.
Get Directions →201 Memory Lane
York, Pennsylvania
Fridays only
Market hours apply
Our York presence—friendly staff, fresh pastries, and full cake selection.
Get Directions →Everything you need to know before placing your first—or next—order.
For birthday and special occasion cakes, we recommend ordering at least one week in advance. For wedding cakes, we suggest scheduling your free consultation 3–6 months before your date to ensure full availability and design time.
Yes. When you schedule a consultation with Diahann, we arrange for you to taste cake flavors and discuss design options. Call (717) 656-6803 to set up your appointment. No commitment required.
Place your order through our website and pick up at our Leola location. Pickup available Monday–Friday 7 AM–5 PM and Saturday 7 AM–2 PM. Curbside delivery is available by request—just let us know when you arrive.
Please call us directly at (717) 656-6803 to discuss your specific needs. We want every celebration to be special and will do our best to accommodate your request on a case-by-case basis.
We offer 7 traditional and 13 specialty flavors, including our signature White Rhapsody—a moist white cake with chocolate shavings, layered with raspberry marmalade and mousse, finished with buttercream. Call for the current full list.
Absolutely. Our miniature dessert selections are perfect for weddings, bridal showers, graduations, and corporate events. Email info@byersbakery.com for custom pricing—all desserts are handmade from our own recipes.
We make ordering straightforward. Call us directly, send a message, or come visit one of our locations. Our team is ready to help you plan something special.
We receive your message and respond within one business day.
We confirm your order details, date, and pickup time.
Your order is baked fresh and ready for pickup.
Three generations. Hundreds of cakes. Thousands of happy families. Let us be part of your most important moments—from everyday mornings to once-in-a-lifetime days.